| Real Estate Market Update | | |  | Housing Market Update Date: 2/6/2011 | | | | |
Informative insight from noted RE analyist Steven Thomas
Quantitative Economics and Decision Sciences, B.A.
President Altera Real Estate
Latest Update: 2/6/2011
Orange County Housing Report: Flashback 2009
January 20, 2011
With the holidays and all of the torrential rains behind us, the Orange County housing market is beginning to thaw and it’s looking a lot like 2009 all over again.
An Accurate Gauge of Market Activity: Pending sales is a far better barometer of what is happening now versus closed sales.
I want to clarify my definition of demand. I track demand as the number of new pending deals over the past month. It is a snapshot of what is going on right now within the Orange County housing market. Ask any buyer, seller or REALTOR® and they would all agree, it is the most accurate gauge on what they are experiencing in the trenches. Many wonder why I don’t emphasize sold data. After all, there are so many short sales that never seem to close and many homes fall out of escrow and are placed right back on the market. As a matter of fact, about 19% of all escrows fall apart for whatever reason. That’s 1 of 5. Yet, sold data is not an accurate gauge of demand TODAY. It tells us a story of what happened about 45 to 60 days back. The market does not adhere to following what happened in the past. Instead, it does whatever it pleases today. Using pending sales over the past month tells us what buyers are willing to do most recently. Every single buyer that enters escrow signed a purchase agreement with the intention to buy. Entering into a pending sale with a short sale that requires lender approval may never close, but if lenders started coming back with immediate approvals, the numbers of sold homes would increase and the fallout rate would drop like a rock. So, the sold data just does not tell enough about what is going on today. Approach the market based upon sold data and you are going to get run over. As the market takes off and heads into the spring market, pending sales are going to climb rapidly, while the sold data will be stuck in the past, a reflection of the holiday market.
Buyer Demand: Demand is revving its engine and is prepared to take off over the coming weeks.
Demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, increased by 10% in the past two weeks, adding an additional 194 homes, and now totals 2,154 pending sales. That’s virtually identical to 2009 when it posted 2,146. Last year, there were 393 additional pending sales, but everybody was poised to take advantage of the $8,000 first time home buyer tax. From here, expect demand to continue to improve as the market prepares to enter the spring market, the strongest time of the year for Orange County housing.
The Active Inventory and Unrealistic Sellers: this is not the market to test the waters with an unrealistic price.
This is my number one concern for the housing market in 2011. 2010 was plagued with unrealistic expectations of the housing market. The inventory grew by 63% unabated for the first nine months of 2010. Both sellers and banks overpriced their homes. Most closed sales last year took place AFTER reducing their prices at least once. A lot of homeowners were not successful at all and opted to take their home off the market during the holidays, throwing in the towel. However, I have already heard anecdotal evidence from REALTORS® in the trenches stating that the same homeowner who pulled their home off the market during the holidays are getting ready to place their home right back on the market at the same unsuccessful price as before. “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results” (Rita Mae Brown). Demand is not going to be much different than 2009, so expectations need to be realigned. Homeowners should only place their homes on the market if and only if they must sell and are willing to do whatever it takes, in terms of price, to be successful. Otherwise, what is the point? In order to properly arrive at value, sellers need to painstakingly, methodically and carefully analyze the most current closed sales and pending sales. The more time spent on arriving at the correct market value, the higher the probability of success. Do not place too much emphasis on the active inventory. It should be utilized only to gauge where your competition’s head is at. Keep in mind, buyers really do not care about what sellers wish they could get for their home. Sellers need to get rid of the concept of pricing their homes based upon what they want to net from the sale. Today’s buyers are spreadsheet buyers, meaning they too are going to study the comparable and pending sales as they don’t want to overpay for a home.
In the past two weeks alone, the active inventory added an additional 238 homes and hurdled right past the 10,000 mark, totaling 10,225 homes. Last year at this time there were 2,545 fewer homes on the market.
Expected Market Time and the Upper Range Vs. the Lower Range: the tale of two markets continues.
For Orange County as a whole, the expected market time dropped from 5.10 months two weeks ago to 4.75 months today. As the market sheds its holiday coat and moves towards the spring, expect the market time to decrease substantially, especially in the lower ranges. Below $1 million, the expected market time is at 4.3 months, technically a week seller’s market. As the market time drops, buyers can expect multiple offers, a lot more competition and sales prices very close to their asking prices. But, don’t expect appreciation even in what is technically a seller’s market. The market is made up of too many distressed homes, which ultimately keeping a lid on appreciation. For homes above $1 million, the expected market time is at 10.67 months, dropping from 12.77 months two weeks ago. However, when an expected market time is in the double digits, 10 or greater, it is a deep buyer’s market with virtually no activity. The upper range will improve a bit, but will remain sluggish throughout the year.
The Distressed Market: do NOT expect much to change with distressed homes; the last two weeks were no exception.
In the past two weeks the active distressed inventory, both foreclosure and short sales, dropped by six homes. Not much has changed since last September, growing by only 78 homes, now totaling 4,117. There are 724 foreclosures on the market, shedding 51 homes in the past two weeks. There are currently 3,393 short sales on the active market with an expected market time of 3.62 months. Expect the distressed inventory to slightly increase as the year progresses; nobody should be expecting a wave of new distressed properties.
Sincerely, Steven Thomas Altera Real Estate
President "Pride Begins at Home”
Copyright 2011 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
December 2010
Orange County Housing Report: Happy New Year – A 2011 Forecast
HAPPY NEW YEAR!!! Now what does that mean for Orange County Real Estate?
First, it is important to clarify that forecasting draws from historical data to predict the future. The fact that forecasts from experts and leading academic institutions have been all over the map is indicative of the uncertainty of the current housing and economic environment. At this point, those that predict the weather are doing a far superior job compared to economists. Forecasting at this point is more of art than an exact science, but I have a pretty strong inclination that the market is not going to change that much. It is going to be a lot more of the same with some minor tweaks. Here’s how I think 2011 will unfold:
· Demand: unlike 2010, demand is going to follow a normal cyclical pattern. Demand was HOT for the first half of 2010 due to the first time home buyer tax credit, and then it fell off a cliff for the second half without any government stimulus. In 2011, there is not a government stimulus program to monkey with demand. For the lower ranges, below $750,000, which accounts for 75% of the listing inventory, the market will become really hot quickly as we roll into the spring. On homes that are priced well, expect a lot of competition with multiple offers and purchase prices very close to their asking prices. This market will remain hot until the market cools in the autumn. For homes priced between $750,000 to $1.5 million, 15% of the active inventory, the market will heat up during the spring, just not as much as the lower ranges. Pricing will be key, as this range tends to be too optimistic right when they first hit the market. For homes priced above $1.5 million, 11% of the active inventory, the market will remain very cold with very little competition. Price is absolutely everything in this range. Unfortunately, this range is made up of the most unrealistic sellers. The problem is that there are just way too many homes on the market all vying for a small pool of potential buyers.
· Pricing: as pointed out above, there are three distinctly different markets in Orange County. As a result, the expectations of pricing should be based upon each price range and not the market as a whole. Regrettably, everybody hangs their hat on the reported median sales price as the best barometer of home values. With three different markets, the median sales price, the middle value, is flawed. In the lower ranges, we can expect very little change in pricing. Keep in mind, that’s 75% of the market. In some really hot areas, the market may even slightly increase. Distressed properties, 49% of the active inventory in the lower ranges, will keep a lid on any real appreciation. For the middle ranges, we can expect slight depreciation in prices. But, with only 17% of this range distressed, the pressure on pricing is not that great. In the upper ranges, distressed properties are not the problem, only 6%. The problem is that there are just too many sellers and not enough buyers. The higher the range, the slower the market. Only those willing to aggressively price their homes will be successful. The pressure on price is greatest in the upper ranges. In this downturn, values in the lower ranges dropped like a rock almost overnight. In the upper ranges, prices have been a lot stickier with fewer distressed homes and a lot more unrealistic homeowners. In 2011, prices will be most volatile in the upper ranges.
· The Active Listing Inventory: the housing market in 2010 was marred by unrealistic homeowners overpricing their homes and sitting on the market. Sellers with equity, sellers without equity and bank foreclosures all fell victim to overpricing. Reports of year over year increases in the median sales price along with reports of tremendous activity and multiple offers mislead everybody in thinking that the market had finally turned. There just are too many distressed homes, high unemployment and uncertainty of the future for values to rise. Instead, buyers have become spreadsheet buyers, pouring over comparable and pending sales, unwilling to pay a premium in order to purchase a home. In 2009, the active listing inventory dropped by 4,000 homes. In 2010, the inventory blossomed, erasing all of the improvements from the year before. In 2011, expect homeowners to have learned their lesson and only enter the market if they really have to sell. The return of the discretionary seller will keep a lid on a rise in the active inventory. This is fundamental to the overall health of the Orange County housing market.
· The Distressed Market: even though the shadow inventory is real, do not expect a wave of distressed properties to hit the market. It was two years ago that many were calling for a tsunami of foreclosures as the government was meeting with banks and the buzz of foreclosure moratoriums was in the air. Yet, it never materialized. There just were too many for the banks to liquidate all at once. A flood of foreclosures would have eroded values even more, more banks would fail and the problem could have snowballed into something much bigger. Ultimately, the banks and the government chose not to go that route. Yes, there are a tremendous number of homeowners who have not paid their mortgages. They just have not materialized as foreclosures. Instead, there is a definite process. Many attempt loan modification, which takes months for an answer. Others try the short sale route, which also takes months for an answer, and can be very complicated to put together. Still, there are others who choose to do nothing, and the banks have been slow to respond. The bottom line, it takes a very long time for distressed properties to move through the system. In the end, it will take years to work our way through the distressed backlog. For 2011, we can expect more of the same, a slight methodical increase in the number of short sales and foreclosures, but no dramatic shifts. Buyers should keep in mind that there is increased competition for distressed properties since all buyers are looking for a deal.
· Interest Rates: about a month ago, I thought the big surprise of 2011 was going to be a rise in interest rates. It turned out to be the big surprise to the end of 2010. Interest rates will still be the big surprise of 2011, with rates reaching the 6% mark. There’s a ton of pressure on rates to increase. An increasing deficit with the Fed printing money at warp speed, a government unwilling to cut spending, and no leader anywhere in the world willing to come up with a definitive game plan to get us out of this pickle, translates to mounting pressure on interest rates. If anybody is in the market to buy, they should pencil out the sizeable increase in monthly payments when rates jump 1%. It illustrates how taking advantage of low rates more than offsets any risk in falling values. Unfortunately, not enough buyers shop for homes based upon monthly payments; instead, they focus on price. It really should be the other way around with rates poised to increase.
· Closed Sales: in 2010, there were about 5% fewer residential resales compared to 2009. For the first half of the year the artificial government stimulus made it appear as if the number of sales was going to rebound for the first time since the downturn began in the autumn of 2005. After the stimulus ended, the market dramatically slowed and the market improvements and momentum faded. In 2011, there will be very close to the same number of sales, just not as lopsided as 2010. Instead, the market will follow a normal Orange County housing cycle: a strong spring market, a slightly cooler summer market, an even cooler autumn market and then the slowest time of the year, the holiday market.
Overall, it looks as if 2011 is going to be a lot like 2010. As a society, the American people are getting all caught up in forecasts and numbers. But, when it comes to housing, we are talking about a place to call “home.” There needs to be a return to finding the right place to call home for years, if not decades. In the past decade, we got caught up in taking out 30-year loans only to refinance every few years, or sell and purchase another, and another. It is time to return to carefully isolating the perfect “home” that best fits our needs, lock in the best interest rates in years, and enjoy life in one of the best places to live in the country. Historically, in the long run, a home is a great investment, especially in Orange County.
Happy New Year!
Sincerely, Steven Thomas Altera Real Estate
President "Pride Begins at Home”
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
November, 2010
Orange County Housing Report: Giving Thanks
It is the time of the year to reflect and give thanks. Regarding the Orange County housing market, there’s still a lot to be thankful for.
Thanksgiving Reflection: Even though the housing market is extremely frustrating, there is plenty to be thankful for.
I am thankful that lenders are approving short sales and that they are closing.
That’s right. I am thankful that lender approval is eventually bestowed upon some short sales, enabling homeowners to escape the nightmare process of selling their underwater homes. I think everybody can agree, including the lenders, that they are still falling way below the bar in terms of making a decision in a reasonable amount of time. There is tremendous room for improvement. The average number of monthly closed short sales this year is 574. Yet, there are 3,045 pending short sales. Most short sales take months for an answer. And, the more complex the short sale, second liens, unpaid homeowner association dues, unpaid property taxes, and mortgage insurance companies, the longer and more challenging it is to successfully close the sale. Yet, I am thankful that some short sales are closing. Lenders are allowing upside down homeowners in dire straits to move on. In turn, they obtain a home typically in better condition and save a lot more money compared to the alternative, foreclosure.
I am thankful that real estate agents are still selling homes despite the tremendous obstacles and frustrations in this market.
Despite misguided public perception, real estate agents in today’s market work ten times harder than any modern era real estate cycle and are paid much less compared to the boom years. Throw on top of that no change in the agent population locally here in Orange County despite the downturn. Here are some of the obstacles they face: tremendous competition, extremely tight credit, short sales that take forever to close, frustrated buyers, sellers in unfortunate situations, and unrealistic expectations of buyers and sellers. Yes, this market has been extremely frustrating, but real estate agents continue to pick themselves up and take great care of their buyers and sellers.
I am thankful that unrealistic sellers are finally figuring it out: if they don’t drop the price, they must pull their home off the market and stop wasting everybody’s time.
The listing inventory blossomed this year, growing from 7,165 homes at the beginning of the year until it peaked in mid-September at 11,892 homes. That’s an increase of 4,727 homes, or 65%. Since peaking, the listing inventory has shed 1,056 homes, or 9%. Unfortunately many homeowners were extremely unrealistic in their expectations of the housing market. They heard about year over year increases in the median sales price, buyers competing to buy homes, multiple offers, and sales price at or above their asking prices. They did not realize that buyers in the most competitive markets were only willing to pay a few thousand dollars above the last asking price, NOT thousands upon thousands of dollars more. Buyers are spreadsheet buyers, meaning they will pour over comparable and pending sales data to arrive at a comfortable price. So, many homeowners placed their homes on the market overpriced and waited and waited with no results. Most homes on the market had to decrease their prices to achieve success. For those unwilling to reduce their asking prices, pulling their homes off of the market is the only other alternative. Distressed properties are keeping a lid on any appreciation. There are still many homeowners that remain on the market at unrealistic levels; however, I am thankful that many of them will be continuing to pull their homes off as the Holiday market progresses.
I am thankful that the market is theoretically a seller’s market, based upon the expected market time.
For a seller’s market, the expected market time must be less than five months. At its best this year, the expected market time dropped to 2.53 months in mid-May. It is currently at 4.02 months, still a seller’s market. But, with so many distressed listings, there is very little appreciation, if any. As long as Orange County’s expected market time indicates a seller’s market, prices will not depreciate. And, it looks as if 2011 is poised to be a seller’s market as well, great news for values.
Active Listing Inventory: The listing inventory continued to drop, shedding 3% in just two weeks.
The active listing inventory continued its decent, dropping 589 homes over the last month, now totaling 10,836. That’s a 5% drop in just four weeks. Many unrealistically priced sellers are starting to realize that throwing in the towel is their best option. Last year at this time there were 3,181 fewer homes on the active inventory compared to today.
Demand: Demand continued its trend of not changing
In the past month, demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, increased by 21 homes, virtually unchanged. Last year at this time demand was at 3,038 pending sales, fueled by a first time home buyer tax credit that was expiring at the end of November 2009.
Foreclosures and Short Sales: It seems as if the plateau in distressed homes on the market has continued.
The active distressed inventory increased by only 40 homes over the past month and now totals 4,101 foreclosures and short sales. The distressed home market is not changing much, adding less than 1% in the past month. It is apparent that the distressed inventory has hit a peak for the year. The distressed inventory now represents 38% of the current active inventory. Last year at this time, there were 2,496 distressed homes on the market, 1,605 fewer than today. The number of foreclosures within the active listing inventory increased by 17 homes in the past two weeks, from 719 to 736. The expected market time for foreclosures is 1.61 months, an exceptionally HOT seller’s market. Short sales, where a homeowner attempts to sell a home for less than the total outstanding loans against a home, requiring lender approval, increased by 20 homes over the past two weeks and now total 3,365. The expected market time for short sales is 3.62 months, not as hot as foreclosures, but better than the Orange County housing market as a whole.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Sincerely, Steven Thomas Altera Real Estate
President "Pride Begins at Home”
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
October 2010
Orange County Housing Report: A Spooktacular Time to Buy
As the goblins, ghosts and zombies scurry from door to door in their quest for sacks full of candy, housing transitions to the Holiday market, the best time of year to buy.
The Holiday Market: From Halloween through the first few weeks of the New Year, it is the perfect time to buy.
On November 1st we quickly transition into the Holiday season as we are bombarded with festive jingles prompting us to purchase gifts for our loved ones. With all of the election hoopla just about over as well, people can’t help but divert their attention to the wonderful distractions of the holidays. Housing is no different. Many buyers sit on sidelines and enjoy the season, only to resume their search just after they forget about their New Year’s resolutions. This is the time of year when housing demand drops, the expected market time climbs and competition wanes. Sellers get it as well. Many have been on the market for months and just don’t want to market their homes during the holidays. Others come to the realization that they may have been unrealistic in their expectations of the market and inadvertently overpriced their homes. This is the perfect time to throw in the towel and pull those overpriced homes off of the market. Typically only the really motivated sellers who have to sell remain on the market. With less competition, low interest rates and motivated sellers, it is a great time to be a buyer. As 2011 rolls along, typically right after the Super Bowl, the market will transition into the Spring market, cyclically the best time of year for Orange County real estate marked with strong demand. If a buyer is looking to buy, ‘tis the season to purchase now!
The Tale of Three Markets: That’s right; there are three distinctly different markets.
Earlier in the year, there were two distinct markets: homes priced below $1 million and homes priced above the same threshold. The lower ranges were red hot and the upper ranges were ice cold. With the housing market transitioning into the Holiday market, there are now three distinct markets: homes priced below $750,000, homes priced between $750,000 and $1.5 million, and homes priced above $1.5 million. We now have a hot, a lukewarm and an ice cold market. For homes priced below $750,000, the expected market time is 3.57months. This range represents 73% of all active listings and 87% of demand. Buyers can expect increased competition, a higher chance of multiple offers, and sales prices close to their asking prices. Prices are stable within this range. For homes priced between $750,000 and $1.5 million, the expected market time is 6.37 months, a slight buyers market. This range represents 16% of the active inventory and 11% of demand. Buyers can expect little competition and a bit of flexibility on behalf of the sellers, but prices are pretty stable, especially below $1 million. For homes priced above $1.5 million, the expected market time is below freezing at 20.57 months. This range represents 12% of the active listing market, but only 2% of demand. Buyers can expect no competition and a lot of pressure on pricing. The problem with this range is that there is a battle between seller stubbornness and market reality. Most sellers at this level are nostalgic and ignore market fundamentals, unrealistically overpricing their homes. Many are substantially overpriced and still very unwilling to budge off of their prices. They forget that buyers no longer buy on a whim, especially with too much supply. Buyers are strategic and approach purchasing very carefully. There is tremendous pressure on pricing in the upper ranges because prices have been a lot stickier and have not fallen yet as much as the lower ranges. They were a bit late to the party. It is basic supply and demand. There are way too many sellers and very few buyers. Specifically, there are 1,337 homes above $1.5 million and only 65 homes placed in escrow over the past month. The probability of success is very low. Motivated sellers priced realistically and able to patiently wait for the right buyer should stick it out. Everybody else really should just pull their homes off of the market.
Active Listing Inventory: The listing inventory continued to drop, shedding another 1% in just two weeks.
The active listing inventory continued its decent, dropping slightly over the last two weeks by 68 homes, now totaling 11,425. Last year at this time there were 3,676 fewer homes on the active inventory compared to today. It appears as if the active listing inventory will start 2011 with more homes than the beginning of this year, but still will end up being the second best start in five years.
Demand: With the Holiday market upon us, demand started its descent.
After a non-cyclical increase in demand two weeks ago, demand, the number of pending sales over the prior month, dropped by 119 pending sales since then, or 4%, and now totals 2,652. Last year at this time demand was at 3,166 pending sales, fueled by a first time home buyer tax credit that was expiring in November 2009.
Foreclosures and Short Sales: In the past six weeks, the active distressed inventory increased by only 35 additional homes.
The active distressed inventory increased by 31 homes over the past two weeks and now totals 4,061 foreclosures and short sales. The distressed home market is not changing much, adding less than 1% in the past two weeks. It is apparent that the distressed inventory has hit a temporary peak for the year. The distressed inventory now represents 36% of the current active inventory. Last year at this time, there were 2,389 distressed homes on the market, 1,672 fewer than today. The number of foreclosures within the active listing inventory dropped by 32 homes in the past two weeks, from 720 to 688. The expected market time for foreclosures is 1.67 months, an exceptionally HOT seller’s market. Short sales, where a homeowner attempts to sell a home for less than the total outstanding loans against a home, requiring lender approval, increased by 63 homes over the past two weeks and now total 3,373. The expected market time for short sales is 3.39 months, not as hot as foreclosures, but better than the Orange County housing market as a whole.
Have a wonderful weekend.
Sincerely, Steven Thomas Altera Real Estate
President "Pride Begins at Home”
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
August 2010
Orange County Housing Report: A Normal End of Summer Cycle
August 19, 2010
Now that Summer is winding down and “back to school” shopping is in vogue, the real estate market is following a normal pattern for this time of year.
Active Listing Inventory: The unabated growth has slowed but still hasn’t reached a peak
The Orange County inventory continued to grow over the past couple of weeks, adding an additional 236 homes and now totals 11,650. This is the highest level since December 2008. With school starting, many homeowners realize that the best time of year to sell has passed them by. As more and more sellers come to grips with the market realities, expect many of them to throw in the towel and pull their homes off the market. There are a lot of equity sellers on the market, nearly 7,900 or 68% of the active market. Many of these sellers will opt to sit out the Autumn and Holiday markets. Last year at this time there were only 8,531 homes on the market, 3,119 fewer than today.
Expected Market Time: The tale of two markets continues and the higher ranges are SLOW.
For homes priced below $1 million, the expected market time is 3.34 months. This range represents 80% of the active inventory and 93% of demand. For homes priced above $1 million, the expected market time is 10.48 months, the higher the range, the slower the expected market time. This range represents 20% of the active inventory, but only 7% of demand. The slowest range, homes priced above $4 million, has an expected market time of 26 months. The hottest market in Orange County is Talega with an expected market time of only 2.22 months. The slowest market in Orange County is Corona del Mar with an expected market time of 11.5 months and an average list price of $3.5 million. Last year at this time the expected market time was 2.43 months.
Housing Demand: Not much of a change in housing demand.
Demand, the number of new pending sales over the past month, increased by only 30 homes in the past two weeks, a 1% increase, and now totals 3,002. That is the first time that demand surpasses the 3,000 mark since the beginning of July. That is still 25% below the end of April peak that totaled 3,979. Last year at this time demand was at 3,506 pending sales, 504 more than today. From here, we can expect demand to slowly drop as we enter the next season of the Orange County housing market, the Autumn market, from the start of school through the pleas of “trick or treat.” From there, housing demand will cool further as we enter the Holiday market, from Halloween through the first couple of weeks of the New Year. There are a lot of distractions during the holidays and real estate typically is placed on the back burner.
Foreclosures and Short Sales: The distressed inventory continues to grow at a very rapid pace.
There really isn’t a “normal cycle” for predicting the level of the distressed inventory throughout the year. When homeowners owe more than their homes are worth and they can no longer afford their monthly payments, they place their homes on the market as short sales regardless of the time of year. Likewise, banks place foreclosures on the market after they have completed the foreclosure process and prepared the homes for sale. This process takes months to complete, so foreclosures are placed on the market regardless of the time of year. We are all acutely aware that there is a “shadow inventory” of homes that are not making their monthly payments and are either attempting to modify their loans, or are trying to sell their homes as short sales, or are staying put and doing nothing. According to various reports the “shadow inventory” totals between five and seven million homes. This shadow inventory has to be worked through, but is not going to occur as a tsunami of distressed properties to hit the market all at once. Instead, we are going to witness slow increases and drops over the next few years. This slow absorption will not pull down values like it did at the beginning of this downturn and it will keep a lid on any substantial appreciation. Once employment improves, the pathway to an eventual healthy and stable recovery will occur. The distressed inventory increased by 182 homes in the past two weeks, the largest increase since December of 2008, and now totals 3,757 homes. Foreclosures increased by only 6 homes in the past two weeks and now total 659. The expected market time for foreclosures is 1.82 months. There are an additional 176 short sales in the past two weeks and now total 3,098. The expected market time for short sales is 2.99 months.
Altera Real Estate "Pride Begins at Home” www.AlteraProperties.com
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
___________________________________________________________
JULY 2010
Orange County Housing Report: Best Time of Year to Sell is Over
July 22, 2010
Finally, summer is here and so are home sellers’ wild expectations.
THE Best Time of Year to Sell: Here’s a hint: it is NOT Summer.
Every year the real estate industry deals with the same cyclical phenomena, homeowners who feel that summer is the best time of year to sell. Unfortunately, buyers do not agree. Buyer activity actually peaks during the spring. Summer is the second best time of the year to sell. Can somebody please communicate that to all of the Sellers who have been fooled and are placing their homes on the market in droves? This year has been no different, and with the end of the Federal $8,000 Tax Credit on April 30th of this year, buyer demand has definitely already peaked. Homeowners are fooled into thinking that the Orange County real estate market is the hottest during the summer because the county is a summertime vacation destination. Since the process in finding a home and closing takes at least a few months, more buyers start looking during the spring. In finding a home during the spring, buyers can close and move over the summer months. So, buyer DEMAND is higher during the spring and CLOSINGS are then higher during the summer. If buyers find something during the summer, they close during the fall. NEWSFLASH: if they have kids, school has already started. For parents, moving while the kids are in school is not typically easy. Thus, parents prefer to close during the summer. We are almost through July, the window of opportunity to close before school starts is fading fast. What is reported by the media does not help either. Newspapers and the nightly news report on SOLD data. Rarely do they talk about current demand, homes placed into pending status. As more and more homeowners hear about the incredible SOLD statistics, they get excited to hear about an increase in the median sales price and an increase in the number of closed sales. The data is very accurate, BUT is a snapshot of activity 45 to 60 days back when the buyers first wrote the offer to purchase, springtime. Homeowners are making decisions based upon what is happening in the rearview mirror. Homeowners need to be aware of current demand, a snapshot of the most recent pending activity. In doing so, they will realize that demand is down 28% since peaking back on April 29th.
Active Listing Inventory: the inventory has grown unabated by 54% so far this year.
The Orange County housing inventory grew by the largest amount so far this year, adding an additional 418 homes in the past two weeks and now totals 11,235. The market has not breached the 11,000 mark since the beginning of April 2009. Last year at this time the inventory was at 8,895 homes, 2,340 fewer than today. The inventory has not stopped growing at all this year as more and more pent up homeowners have opted to place their homes on the market at unrealistic levels. The same media reports of median home price increases and year over year increases in the number of closed sales have fooled these pent up sellers into believing that the market has recovered and that it is a great time to take advantage of the market. It is true that agents have tons of buyers in the market that have written many unsuccessful offers thus far and homes that are priced well are receiving multiple offers. The market disconnect lies in the fact that inventory has been increasing on the backs of unrealistic homeowners who have placed their homes on the market at overpriced levels. Today’s “spreadsheet buyers” are not willing to pay much of a premium for a home just to end their unsuccessful string of offers. They will maybe pay an extra few thousand dollars, but not the 5 to 10% premium many sellers are vying for. As more overpriced homes are placed on the market, it is just a matter of time before buyers start getting discouraged and slow their effort in finding a home.
Housing Demand: Not much of a change in demand.
It is important to reiterate that demand has already dropped 28% since peaking in the Spring. The drop has been more profound this year due to the end of the Federal First Time Home Buyer Tax Credit at the end of April. Demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, increased by 10 in the past two weeks and now totals 2,870. From here, demand typically rises slightly and peaks at the end of August before slowly deteriorating for the remainder of the year. Last year at this time demand was at 3,306 pending sales, 436 more than today.
Expected Market Time: After bottoming in April, the expected market time for OC homes has increased by 66%
With an increase in the active listing inventory and almost no change in demand, the expected market time increased from 3.78 months two weeks ago to 3.91 months today. The overall market is still a “seller’s market,” but it is moving in the wrong direction. Remember, this seller’s market is different. There may be a lot of buyers and a lot of competition, but spreadsheet buyers are unwilling to pay much of a premium over the last comparable sale. At the end of April, the expected market time was at 2.35 months. Last year at this time the expected market time was at 2.69 months. For homes priced above $1 million, the expected market time is 10.68 months. Contrast that with homes priced below $1 million where the expected market time is 3.37 months.
Foreclosures and Short Sales: Over the past two weeks the active distressed inventory has grown the most this year.
The active distressed inventory grew by 150 homes over the past two weeks and now totals 3,457 total foreclosures and short sales, levels not seen since May of 2009. The active distressed inventory started the year with 2,555 homes and has since grown by 35%. The distressed inventory now represents 31% of the current active inventory. Last year at this time, there were 2,616 distressed homes on the market, 841 fewer than today. The number of foreclosures within the active listing inventory increased by 35 homes in the past two weeks from 578 to 613. The expected market time for foreclosures is 1.79 months, an exceptionally HOT seller’s market. Short sales, where a homeowner attempts to sell a home for less than the total outstanding loans against a home, requiring lender approval, increased by 115 homes over the past two weeks and now total 2,844. The expected market time for short sales is 2.71 months, still a HOT seller’s market, but slower than the 1.53 month market back in April.
Altera Real Estate "Pride Begins at Home” www.AlteraProperties.com
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
___________________________________________________________
MAY / JUNE 2010
June 10, 2010
Orange County Housing Report: Demand Returning to Normal
The drop in demand ever since the end of the Federal first time home buyer tax credit on April 30th is slowing and leveling off.
Housing Demand: The 4% drop in demand in the last two weeks is much better than the 12% posted two weeks ago.
At this point, looking in the rearview mirror, the end of the Federal tax credit definitely had an impact on Orange County housing demand. It is also safe to say that demand prompted many first time home buyers to purchase sooner than originally anticipated. Had the credit not been in place, demand would have been curtailed in both March and especially April. Demand in May and June would have been stronger as well. March and April’s surge due to the housing credit robbed May and June of normal activity. There is nothing cyclical about the recent swings in demand, but it is making its way back to normal. It should be back on track by July. Demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, decreased by 136 in the past two weeks and now totals 3,167. That is after a 603 home drop two weeks ago. For the first time since March 2008, demand is less than the prior year with 485 fewer pending sales. Hold your horses if you are a buyer; this does not mean that it’s going to get much easier for buyers anytime soon. The demand trend is now going to change back to a more normal pattern. The expected market time for all homes priced below $1 million is still a very hot 2.71 months. Five months is equilibrium. Anything less than five months is a seller’s market. You may ask, “How can we have a seller’s market without rampant appreciation?” The answer is quite simple: with so many distressed homes on the market, they are keeping a lid on any real, significant appreciation. Anything higher than five months is considered a buyer’s market. For homes priced above $1 million, the upper end, the expected market time is 8.89 months, the higher the price range, the slower the market If you are a buyer, carefully consider the local market conditions and the price range you are looking. For example, homes priced between $1 million and $1.5 million, the expected market time is 5.59, not really a buyer’s nor a seller’s market.
Active Listing Inventory: For the first time since April of last year, the inventory has crossed the 10,000 home mark.
Last year, after increasing by less than 400 homes in the first three months, the total active inventory steadily dropped from a height of 11,606 homes to 7,381, a 4,225 drop or 36%. This year the Orange County housing market has experienced the exact opposite phenomena, increasing unabated by 39% to 10,117. In the past two weeks, the inventory has grown by 278 homes, a 3% increase. This also marks the first time since April 2008 where the inventory is higher than the prior year. Last year the inventory was at 9,313 homes, 804 fewer than today. What is going on? The answer is quite simple: there are more and more unrealistic homeowners placing their homes on the market at unrealistic levels. They have learned that the market is hot in the lower ranges with buyers competing for homes that generate multiple offers and ultimately sell for their full asking prices. However, buyers are just not ready to pay substantially more than the last comparable closed or pending sale. Sure, given the heated demand, they may pay $5,000 more than the last buyer, but no buyer is prepared to pay a $40,000 premium for a home. Many of these homeowners have been sitting on the fence, unable to sell, waiting for the market to turn so that they can finally achieve what they have been putting off for a while now, moving. The Orange County market was blessed in 2008 and 2009 with discretionary homeowners. They knew that buyers would not pay a premium, so only homeowners that had to sell placed their homes on the market and, most importantly, at realistic levels. If you are a seller and your home is not generating enough activity and not procuring offers, now is a great time to take a careful look at PRICE. Keep in mind; just because you are an equity seller, buyers are not going to pay you a substantial premium so that they don’t have to deal with all of the hassles in purchasing foreclosures or short sales. Again, a $5,000 premium is more realistic. Many foreclosures and short sales have a ton of upgrades, part of the excess of the last run-up in values. So, as a seller, it is absolutely imperative to do your homework by carefully considering three important factors: location, condition and amenities. A buyer is going to do the same thing. It is important to be able to take a step back, pulling out the emotion of “yeah, but this is my home,” and objectively arriving at the fair market value.
Foreclosures and Short Sales: 30% of the current active inventory is distressed.
The distressed inventory continued its slow climb this year, adding an additional 89 homes in the prior two weeks and now totaling 3,080, a 3% increase. The inventory has not surpassed the 3,000 mark since June of last year. Last year at this time, there were 3,062 distressed homes on the market, representing 33% of the active inventory. The number of foreclosures within the active listing inventory dropped by three homes in the past two weeks from 533 to 530. The expected market time for foreclosures is 1.45 months, an extremely HOT seller’s market. Short sales, where a homeowner attempts to sell a home for less than the total outstanding loans against a home, requiring lender approval, increased by 92 homes over the past two weeks and now total 2,550. The expected market time for short sales is 2.09 months, also a HOT seller’s market.
Closed Sales: May will prove to be one of the best months in terms of closed sales in 2010.
The number of closed residential resale homes in May totaled 2,789 homes, a 13% increase year over year. But, keep in mind that the tax credit for first time home buyers is for successful contracts that are consummated on or before April 30, 2010, and must close on or before June 30, 2010. The tax credit may have ended for all buyers still looking for a home, but still applies to buyers who put together a contract prior to April 30th and still able to close by the end of this month. Just as there was a surge in demand in March and April, the surge continued in terms of sales in May and will continue this month. We can expect headlines to reflect this surge when they report May sales later this month.
"Pride Begins at Home” www.AlteraProperties.com
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
_____________________________________________________________
APRIL 2010
Orange County Housing Report: End of Credit Won’t End Demand
April 29, 2010
Good Afternoon!
At the stroke of midnight on April 30th the Federal first time home buyer tax credit will end, but there is just too much demand for it to spell the end to demand. Everybody within the real estate trenches, blogs and media have been looking to the end of the tax credit like the infamous Y2K predictions of a little more than decade ago. Remember those days? I had a neighbor who bought a trash can from the local hardware store and filled it with bottled water and canned goods claiming that the end of life as we knew it was upon us. Governments, banks, power companies, airports, traffic systems and more were all supposed to fail on the first day of the year 2000. Nothing really happened. For Orange County real estate, the end of the tax credit is not going to have much of an impact either. Don’t get me wrong; all of the government stimulus has definitely had a profound impact of the real estate market right in our very own backyard; however, it is time to move on. The program has to end sometime and it might as well be during the hottest time of the year, the Spring market. Yes, we have had buyers hurry to cash in on the credits, but there are enough first time home buyers that have been unsuccessful in purchasing thus far that will still be looking. The reports from the trenches are that these buyers are not about to do an about face and leave the market with their tales between their legs. More recently, many buyers saw the credit as a perk. The new California tax credit that starts this Monday is only going to last about a week due to the fact that only 17,500 first time home buyers in ALL of California will obtain the $10,000 credit (spread over three years) before the funds runs out. Yet, when California announced the credit about a month ago, demand was already hot. It did nothing to instigate more demand. The problem has been not enough supply in the lower ranges where first time home buyer activity is the greatest, not a lack of demand. Also, first time home buyer activity has been bumping along at about 25% of total activity. It is not going to drop significantly and there are plenty of non-first time home buyers in the marketplace as well.
Interest Rates: Rates are expected to rise which drops home affordability.
Buyers are motivated to purchase knowing that the expected rise in interest rates will ultimately make their payments go up. But, it is more than that. As interest rates rise, buyers can afford less of a home. This is best illustrated in an example. For a buyer with an income of $100,000 and putting 20% down, a rise in interest rates from 5% to 6% equates in in home affordability from $590,000 to $540,000, a $50,000 drop. With the government no longer committing to purchasing pools of loans, which ended on March 31st, interest rates are expected to rise a full percent over the coming year.
Housing Demand: Demand has not seen these levels since June of 2005
Demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, increased by 231 homes over the prior two weeks and now totals 3,979, a 3% increase and the height thus far in 2010. Demand is 347 pending sales stronger than last year at this time and 1,439 stronger than two years ago. Demand should hit a plateau through the remainder of the Spring market.
Active Listing Inventory: The active inventory has continued its gradual climb and just reached levels not seen since June of last year.
Over the past two weeks, the inventory has increased by 174 homes to 9,351, a 2% increase. We started the year at 7,165 listings and have added 2,186 homes to the active inventory to date. Last year, the inventory continued to drop from mid-March to the New Year. The increase seems gradual, but when looked at since the beginning of the year, a 31% increase is pretty profound. Agents in the trenches are stating that there are more overpriced, unrealistic sellers placing their homes on the market. Prior to the start of the year I forecasted that the discretionary seller would return; however, if more and more homes are placed on the market at unrealistic values, the inventory will continue to rise. This rise in inventory could dampen demand. This is a trend that we will have to continue to watch. If you are a homeowner contemplating placing your home on the market much higher than the most recent comparable sales and pending activity, the current market will not support your line of thinking. Buyers are not willing to pay a sizeable sum extra for a home simply because there is more demand and more competition. There is just too much distress that remains in the market and the distressed market is keeping a lid on appreciation.
Expected Market Time: Every price range experienced a drop in the expected market time.
The expected market time for all of Orange County dropped slightly from 2.45 months two weeks ago to 2.35 months today. Yet, there still are two distinct markets: homes priced below $1 million, HOT, and homes priced above $1 million COLD. It is important to note that the lower the range, the HOTTER the market. For homes priced below $500,000, the hottest range, the expected market time is 1.6 months. Compare that to homes priced above $4 million where the expected market time is a frigid 29.5 months.
Distressed Inventory: The number of active foreclosures increased while the number of active short sales decreased.
The number of active distressed homes on the market, all short sales and foreclosures combined, increased by only 9 homes in the past two weeks and now total 2,790, or 29.8% of the current active inventory. Last year at this time, there were 3,724 distressed homes on the market, representing 35.9% of the active inventory. The number of foreclosures within the active listing inventory increased by 38 homes in the past two weeks from 416 to 454. The expected market time for foreclosures is 1.12 months, an extremely HOT seller’s market. Short sales, where a homeowner attempts to sell a home for less than the total outstanding loans against a home, which requires lender approval, decreased by 29 homes over the past two weeks and now total 2,336. The expected market time for short sales is 1.53 months, also a HOT seller’s market. Everybody’s looking for a deal, so there’s a lot of competition in purchasing foreclosures and short sales.
Have a wonderful weekend.
"Pride Begins at Home” www.AlteraProperties.com
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
_____________________________________________________________
February 2010
Orange County Housing Report: February 4, 2010
The Housing Market Accelerates
Now that the holidays are now a distant memory and everybody has become accustom to writing 2010 in place of 2009, buyers have turned their collective heads back to Orange County real estate. The Super Bowl typically marks the beginning of Orange County’s Spring market, and this year proves to be no exception. Demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, soared and grew by 28% over the past two weeks to 3,248, adding 701 additional pending sales. Over the past month, demand has increased by 43%. There are 577 additional pending sales compared to last year and 1,680 compared to two years ago. Last year demand did not reach current levels until April. This is a pretty good start to the Spring market for Orange County, the strongest demand at the beginning of the year since 2005.
So, how do the rest of the numbers look? The active inventory increased over the past two weeks by 177 homes, or 2%, to 7,857. The active inventory last year was at 11,519, 3,662 additional homes compared to today. Two years ago it was at 15,259, 7,402 additional homes. The expected market time for all price ranges in Orange County dropped from 3.02 months just two weeks ago to 2.42 months today. There is a lot of confusion about the housing market because there are really three markets: less than $750,000, $750,000 to $1.5 million, and $1.5 million plus. For all homes less than $750,000, the
market is ON FIRE with multiple offers and sales prices above the list prices. When the expected market time drops below two months, the market is crazy with a lot of competition. The $750,000 to $1.5 million range is getting hotter and many are experiencing multiple offers. There are more jumbo loan products available with much more attractive rates. For homes above $1.5 million, the market is as cold as ice, the higher the range, the colder the market. There simply are fewer buyers looking for homes in these ranges and loan products are much harder to obtain and have much higher interest rates. The active distressed home market, all short sales and foreclosures combined, actually bucked a 12 week trend and dropped by 22 homes to 2,651. That does not mean that there are fewer distressed homes coming on the market; rather, it means that the increased demand is eating up the active distressed inventories. Over the past month, the number of distressed and non-distressed homes to hit the market has been increasing, but many are going off the market as pending sales just as quickly as they are coming on. The number of foreclosures increased in the past two weeks from 355 to 375. The expected market time for foreclosures is a sizzling 0.90 months, a deep seller’s market. Foreclosures garner so much activity that they are like individual mini auctions and the successful buyer is really the successful bidder. The number of short sales on the active inventory decreased by 69 and now totals 2,249. The expected market time for short sales is 1.63 months, also a deep seller’s market. 33.7% of the active inventory is distressed. Last year at this time 44% of the inventory was distressed. In January, 29% of all sales were short sales, 17% were foreclosures and 54% were equity sellers. In January 2009, 19% of sales were short sales, 44% were foreclosures and 37% were equity sellers. The mix has changed with increases in the number of short sales and equity sellers.
If you are a seller, how should you approach the market? Just because the market is really hot, does not mean it is appreciating out of control. Distressed homes are keeping a lid on appreciation. Instead, in approaching pricing, it is very important to take a close look at recent comparable sales and all pending activity. Listed homes do not necessarily help much in pricing, other than to see if somebody is pricing too aggressively. Keep in mind, that sometimes homes are placed on the market far below the true market value and they generate so much activity, that the end result is that it sells for the true market value, selling for thousands above the list price. This is a market reality. The higher the price, the more careful sellers need to be in pricing their homes. They also need to be patient and in tune with how the market is reacting to their homes. Showing feedback is crucial in keeping in touch with how the market is responding to a home. Did the buyer buy something else? What did they like and dislike about the home? Do they have any suggestions in marketing the home? The answers to these questions can help steer a listed home to successfully procuring an offer and ultimately selling the home.
If you are a buyer, how should you approach the market? First, a buyer needs to know the market for the home that they are looking for. The price range is the biggest factor. It is very hard for buyers to swallow the fact that the lower ranges are unbelievably hot. Competing with multiple offers is hardly the expectations a buyer has stepping into the housing market. I have heard story after story that it often takes one or two losing offers before a buyer digs in, sharpens their pencil and writes a strong offer. Considering that all homes in all ranges sold for 98% of their list prices last month, there just is not a lot of flexibility. For lower range and distressed homes, there is even less flexibility and many are selling above their list prices. So, it is better to understand that this hotter market is a reality and has been around since about March of 2009. Otherwise, buyers are left learning the hard way, shaking their heads in frustration. Buyers have been reacting by either withdrawing from the market, anticipating that the market will drop down the road with the economy still in such disrepair. Or, buyers become more realistic and adjust to the unexpected market realities. For this year, the market appears to be repeating 2009 numbers with a bit more activity, especially in the lower ranges. Short sales are going to dominate the market and the lengthy short sale approval process is only going to get better as the year unfolds. Interest rates are at historically low levels and are expected to rise later this year.
"Pride Begin s at Home”
www.AlteraProperties.com
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
_________________________________________________________
January 2010
Orange County Housing Report: January 7, 2010
The Best Start in Years
This is the best start to a New Year for the Orange County housing market in years. Low interest rates, tax credits, increased home affordability, increased conventional loan limit, U.S. Treasury purchases of paper, Federal Housing Administration loans have all had a positive influence on the housing market. In looking at the numbers, the Orange County housing market has not started this strong since prior to the current downturn. Demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, may have dropped by 10%, or 250 homes, in the past two weeks to 2,265, but a giant drop after the New Year is a common cyclical phenomena year in and year out. More telling is that current demand is the highest initial posting since January of 2004. Last year demand was at 2,008 and two years ago it was at 998 (not a typo). The active listing inventory dropped by 88 homes in the past two weeks to 7,293. This too is just normal cyclical behavior for the beginning of a year. What stands out is that the inventory is at its lowest start in five years. In 2009, the active listing inventory started the year at 11,287. Two years ago it was 14,944. With a smaller inventory and higher demand, the expected market time is currently at a healthy 3.22 months. That is much better than 5.62 months in 2009 or 14.97 months in 2008. So, the Orange County housing market is in a much better position right out of the 2010 gates compared to the last
several years. Absent any distressed homes, the market is poised to appreciate. But, let’s not get carried away. Distressed properties are keeping a lid on appreciation and a lack jumbo financing and tight lender requirements have sapped the life out of demand in the upper end. These caveats to the great start in 2010 are going to be a major factor throughout this year’s housing market.
A closer look at the Distressed Inventory: Everybody is talking about distressed properties in one way or another. The constant drone about the “shadow inventory” is deafening. However, the “wave of foreclosures” has not materialized in the past 12 months that everybody has been talking about it. WARNING: DO NOT GRAB YOUR SURFBOARD BECAUSE THERE IS NO WAVE. If you think that lenders are suddenly going to unleash a massive number of foreclosures onto the market, you are fooling yourself. The wave is not going to materialize. There is already a wave that has manifested itself over the course of the past two years and it is not a wave of foreclosures; it is a wave of short sales. Short sales are going to dominate the distressed market in 2010. The federal government has been meeting with the big banks ever since this bubble burst and defaults started to skyrocket to economic unhealthy levels. We first heard about foreclosure moratoriums. Then we heard about loan modifications. Both were heavily encouraged by the federal government. Moratoriums only stall the inevitable. Loan modifications have not been that successful, but I have heard a anecdotal evidence that there are a lot more successful loan modifications than what is currently being reported. Now, the federal government has set their sights on short sales. If homeowners do not qualify for loan modifications, then the government wants the big banks to turn to short sales and streamline the process. Foreclosures will become the option of last resort. When all else fails, the banks will foreclose. From my perspective, the short sale route is a much better alternative for banks than foreclosing. Short sale listings are often in great condition and there is still pride in the home. Short sale listings are often marketed fully furnished and are clean and ready to go. Foreclosures, on the other hand, are often dilapidated with broken windows, holes in the walls, missing appliances and fixtures, green pools, dead landscaping and are in overall poor condition. The problem is that a homeowner that loses their home to foreclosure is often despondent and no longer cares about their home as they vacate. If there are occupants, the bank has to endure the long process of eviction. Delays are inevitable, making the foreclosure route lengthy and unpalatable. Short sales lack most of the problems inherent with foreclosures and, in a sense, are working with the homeowner. It is a much more civilized alternative to foreclosure when there are so many distressed homeowners. The only real problem with short sales is that not all lenders have their act together in dealing with the heavy load of current short sales in the system. Short sales require lender approval as they are asking for the bank to accept taking less than what is owed on a home. With a giant drop in values over the past several years, many homeowners owe more than their homes are worth. If a homeowner cannot afford their payment or they lose their job, they must sell their home as a short sale to minimize any credit damage. Yet, only a few lenders are able to make a decision quickly. On November 30, 2009, the Treasury outlined the short sale process for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans. FHA loans followed suit with a guideline in the middle of December. Many banks are preparing, or have already prepared, a streamlined short sale process. 2010 is the year of the short sale and we will undoubtedly witness a lot more successful short sales compared to foreclosures. Currently there are 2,555 distressed homes on the active market, an increase of 46 in the past month and 166 in the past 10 weeks. That represents 35% of the current active inventory. Of the 2,555, only 375 are foreclosures and 2,180 are short sales. There are over 7,000 short sales that are either active listings on the market, pending sales, or are currently on “Hold” in Orange County alone. That’s already a pretty decent base to rolling out the new short sale processes, which will clean up the local inventory. But, not every sale is going to be distressed. Last month, 17% of the closed sales were foreclosures, 25% were short sales and 58% were equity sellers. The distressed market is a large part of our current market, but there are still plenty of sellers with equity.
"Pride Begin s at Home”
www.AlteraProperties.com
Copyright 2010 - Steven Thomas, Altera Real Estate - All Rights Reserved. This report may not be reproduced in whole or part without express written permission by author.
______________________________________________________
October 2009
Orange County Housing Report: October 29th, 2009
Lack of Inventory is SPOOKY
Keeping with the cries for “trick or treat,” the Orange County housing market has its own eerie trick, an incredible lack of inventory for homes priced below $1 million. The other day I was asked what one thing spooks me the most about the real estate market right now and the crazy inventory was my answer. There is very little fresh, new inventory. The lower the range, the “spookier” it gets. Properties that are priced right and in great condition are flying off of the market with multiple offers and tremendous activity. Buyers new to the market are dumbfounded by all of the competition. Their expectations are of doom and gloom and the ability to “cherry pick” whatever home they are interested in AND at a discount. Yet, just about every agent has pockets filled with buyers who want to buy but have been unable to purchase after losing out on property after property. For most, it is not the first time home buyer credit that is motivating them, as it is set to expire at the end of November anyhow (there is an extension that is in the works though). Many buyers don’t even qualify for the credit due to income requirements. Affordability, low rates and a fear that rates will increase from their historically low levels has motivated people to jump into the market. On average, agents are writing several offers for every buyer. To top it off, investors are back in the real estate game and pushing out buyers with smaller down payments. FHA (Federal Housing Administration) financing allows for a small down payment, but buyers electing to utilize this program simply are finding it impossible to purchase. We have seen prices increasing in the lower ranges slightly, but distressed properties are keeping a lid on stronger appreciation. The "shadow inventory" of foreclosed properties sitting on the sidelines and not yet on the market due to foreclosure moratoriums, government intervention, or banks careful not to flood the market, has only compounded the problem of a lack of inventory. Even if the strategy were to change and more of the “shadow inventory” hit the market, demand is currently strong enough to quickly sop it up. However, buyers should not expect foreclosures to flood the market all at once, lenders and the government are not interested in eroding values further. Instead, when the market heats up in the spring we can probably expect an increase in foreclosure activity to parallel an increase in demand. This housing downturn has been full of surprises and this year's "spooky" twist has been an unexpected drop in the inventory.
So, how do the numbers look? The market really has not changed much over the past few months. The past two weeks are definitely no exception. There have been no surprises other than the continued descent in the housing inventory. The active listing inventory decreased by 174 homes over the past two weeks, totaling 7,749. We have not seen the inventory this low since the beginning of January 2006. That’s 5,041 fewer than last year and 9,705 fewer than two years ago. The inventory has dropped by 4,093 homes so far this year, a 35% drop. We can expect the active listing inventory to drop slightly for the remainder of the year. Demand, the number of new pending sales within the past month, dropped by 31 in the past couple of weeks to 3,166, a 1% drop. Last year’s demand was 703 fewer and two years ago was 1,925 fewer. For the remainder of the year, as we enter the Holiday market, we can expect demand to continue to slowly drop as the distractions of Thanksgiving, unwrapping presents and ringing in a New Year sets in. The expected market time for all of Orange County decreased ever so slightly in the past couple of weeks from 2.48 to 2.45 months. The expected market time last year was at 5.19 months and two years ago it was at 14.06 months. That’s correct. The current expected market time for the entire market, including the sluggish upper end, is two-and-a-half months. For homes priced below $1 million, the expected market time is 1.89 months. For homes priced above $1 million, the expected market time is 9.27 months. That’s because that range represents 29% of the active listing inventory, BUT just 8% of demand. There is actually okay activity up to $2 million, nothing to write home about, but some movement. For the 1,039 homes priced above $2 million, the expected market time is in the double digits, a crawl. After increasing for the first time this year two weeks ago, the number of distressed properties on the market decreased by 9 homes. 31% of the active inventory is distressed compared to 43% last year. There are currently only 314 foreclosures in all of Orange County, a decrease of eight in the past two weeks. The numbers have not really changed much since July. Foreclosures only represent 4% of the active listing market and have an expected market time of 0.69 months. Last year the expected market time was at 1.22 months. Foreclosures continue to be exceptionally HOT and are, on average, selling for 3% above their asking prices. Buyers should be aware that it is a feeding frenzy out there for foreclosures. Realistic expectations are that the more qualified borrower able to bring in a strong offering price is going to ultimately prevail. Buyers with smaller down are going to find it difficult to compete. There are currently 2,075 short sales on the active market, a decrease of just one home in the past two weeks. Short sales currently represent 27% of the active listing inventory, a major player in today’s marketplace. The expected market time for short sales is currently at 1.85 month versus 6.92 months one year ago. Remember, there is nothing “short” about a short sale. Short sales, where the homeowner owes more than the home is worth, are subject to loan approval and can take anywhere from weeks to months to secure that approval.
________________________________________________________
August 2009
Orange County Housing Report: August 6, 2009
Demand is Up and Supply is Down
As is typical for this time of year, demand increased a bit at the beginning of August; however, the continuous drop in the active listing inventory is far from ordinary. Inventories have been dropping across the nation and Orange County is no exception. Since March of this year, the active inventory has been steadily dropping. The inventory has shed 2,925 homes since then, a 25% drop. Currently at 8,681 homes, that is far fewer than the 14,348 last year or 17,611 two years ago. So, what’s going on? Prices are down, interest rates are down, affordability is up and demand is up. All of these forces together have been pulling the inventory down. Throw in the fact that discretionary homeowners are only placing their homes on the market if they have to and are motivated to do what it takes to compete in this market. Demand, the number o f new pending sales within the past month, is currently at 3,481, an increase of 165 pending sales within the last two weeks. Last year demand was at 2,940. So, with an increase in demand and a lower inventory, the market has heated up. The expected market time for all of Orange County is currently at 2.5 months, technically a seller’s market. The lower the range, the hotter the market. All ranges below $1 million are pretty hot, but homes priced below $500,000 are sizzling. The expected market time for homes priced between $250,000 and $500,000 is currently at 1.30 months. For detached homes within that range, the expected market time is only 1.02 months. When the expected market time drops to such low levels, sellers are busy sorting through multiple offers and buyers are writing offer after offer with no luck. I have been asked many times why the market is not appreciating given all of the activity. The devil is in the details. Even though the distressed inventory has been dropping and now represents 29.5% of the current active inventory, 50% of current demand is distressed properties. With so many short sales and foreclosures driving demand, these distressed sellers are keeping a lid on any price appreciation. But, don’t misinterpret me. There may be a lid on appreciation, but in the hotter areas and price ranges there is also a lid on price depreciation. Values have fallen significantly since the start of this downturn, fueled by a consistent supply of distressed properties. So, current values have reached affordable levels where it makes sense again to own versus rent. First time home buyer activity has returned with a vengeance as well. Throw in the return of investor activity and it is no wonder that demand has increased this year.
How do the distressed numbers look? First off, the “next wave” of foreclosures that we have been hearing about since the beginning of the year still has not materialized. I have been hearing from industry experts and agents alike that the next wave is still coming. I am certain that they are right to a degree, that the distressed numbers will increase, just not at the great numbers that they are anticipating. The agents on the streets are telling me that they all have pockets full of buyers waiting for the right property to come onto the market and they all would love a “foreclosure deal.” This is where pent up demand really does exist. Any surge in foreclosures would be met with buyers in waiting. We can expect a lot of competition and continued multiple offers for some time to come. There are currently only 2,559 distressed homes on the market, a drop of 57 in the past two weeks. This is the lowest drop in the distressed inventory since February of this year. Could we be reaching a plateau before the overly predicted wave to come? Only time will tell. There are only 299 foreclosures currently on the active market with demand at 590, representing an expected market time of .51 months. That’s correct, two weeks. Foreclosures are so incredibly hot that they can generate 20 plus offers. Yet, only one gets the property. Demand is plentiful, there just is not enough supply. There are 2,260 short sales on the active market with demand at 1,145 and an expected market time of 1.97 months.
If you are a buyer, how should you respond to this market? First, please throw out the notion that there is no competition and that you can write an offer for thousands less than the asking price. The sales to list price ratio for homes priced below $500,000 is 100%. That means that, on average, homes are selling for their full asking price. For all homes in Orange County, the sales to list price ratio is 98%. Remember, homes have already dropped 30% or more in value. As a buyer, do NOT write an offer for 10% or more off of the asking price with a letter detailing that the housing market is currently in a declining market. These buyers feel that the ultimate sales price should reflect a future drop in values. That notion of purchasing is ludicrous. Industry experts and economists cannot accurately determine future prices and are constantly revising their estimates. The values are already highly discounted over the past few years. Arriving at the fair market value includes taking into consideration pending activity, recent sales (within the prior 90 days), property condition, seller motivation and circumstances, location, upgrades, lot size and amenities. To rely on Zillow.com or other online valuation tools is also absurd. These tools only take into consideration property size and sales price, ignoring all of the other factors that are used to arrive at price. There has been a lot of pressure on interest rates to move higher. Gone are the days of interest rates below 5%. As interest rates rise, affordability drops. In purchasing today, the monthly payment is approximately the same as a home purchased later with a drop of 10% in value and a 1% rise in interest rates. These historically low interest rates are not here to stay. How long they remain low is anybody’s guess. Last, buyers should only purchase in today’s market if and only if they plan on living in their home for years to come. In the long run, Orange County housing has proven to be an excellent long term investment. It is also a great place to call “home.”
_________________________________________________________
April 2009
Orange County Housing Report: April 30, 2009
The Distressed Inventory is Dropping

The total number of distressed properties, foreclosures and short sales, dropped to its lowest level since December 27, 2007. There are currently 3,724 distressed homes on the active market, 37% off of the peak of 5,950 established in August 2008. The number of active foreclosures has dropped from its November 2008 peak of 1,404 to 529, a 62% drop. It is not just the number of foreclosures that has been dropping; the number of short sales on the active market has dropped by 20% since February, from 4,009 to 3,195. This drop can be directly attributed to much stronger demand for homes priced below $1 million, which accounts for 74% of the active inventory and 95% of demand. Homes above $1 million account for 5% of demand, but 26% of the active inventory. Demand has been incredibly strong in the lower ranges because of two factors: 96% of all distressed properties are found below $1 million; and, jumbo loans, loans above $729,750, are much harder to obtain than conventional loans, loans below that level.
For Orange County, demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, increased by an additional 79, now totaling 3,632 and the current height of demand for 2009. Orange County demand has not been at this level since August of 2005, just prior to the beginning of the current cycle. Last year there were 1,092 fewer pending sales, totaling 2,540, 30% less. Two years ago demand was 1,769 fewer, totaling 1,863, 49% less. Three years ago demand was 26% less and totaled 2,701. The recent surge in demand seems to be abating, but this can be attributed to less inventory in the lower ranges. With an expected market time of 1.73 months, the $250,000 to $500,000 range has been incredibly hot and many buyers have written offer after offer with no success. The sales to list price ratio for homes within this range is 100%. So, those buyers looking to scoop up a deal by writing for less than the asking price are, on average, out of luck. The sales to list price ratio for foreclosures within that range is 101%.
The active listing inventory dropped 198 homes in the past two weeks to 10,363. The inventory has not been at these levels since April 2006. At the start of the year the active inventory was at 11,842, 1,479 additional homes compared to today. Last year there were 15,437 homes on the market, 5,074 additional homes compared. Two years ago there were 15,519 homes on the market, 5,156 additional homes. Three years ago there were 11,956 homes on the market, 593 additional homes compared to today. The expected market time dropped from 2.97 months two weeks ago to 2.85 months today. The expected market time last year was at 6.08 months, two years ago it was at 8.33 months, and three years ago it was at 4.43 months. This is the lowest expected market time since October 2005. Total Orange County pending sales continues its surge, reaching record heights for this three and one-half year downturn, totaling 5,733, an 828 home increase over the past month. Last year at this time, total pending sales reached 3,514, 2,219 fewer than today. Two years ago it was at 2,824, 2,909 fewer. Total pending count is different than demand because demand tracks new pending sales over the past month. Total pending count takes into account all pending sales, including those that have been pending for longer than 30-days. The 5,733 tabulation indicates that there will be a surge in sales over the next couple of months.

How should a buyer approach this market? Most buyers have the wrong expectations in approaching the Orange County real estate market. Everybody is acutely aware of the current global recession caused by the financial crunch, so it is understandable that today’s buyers want a deal when buying a home. However, buyers fail to consider two important aspects of the current real estate market: there is tremendous demand for lower priced homes and distressed properties; and, today’s asking prices already reflect a major drop in value. Prices have reached much more affordable levels just as interest rates have dropped to historical lows, the end result, demand not seen prior to the current downturn. So, buyers need to take a litmus test of the market that they are interested in. Buyers can expect multiple offers and even above asking price sales prices for homes priced below $500,000 and distressed homes. The market has heated up considerably for homes priced between $500,000 and $750,000 as well, with an expected market time of 2.49 months. The market is much stronger between $750,000 and $1 million too, with an expected market time of 4.95 months, considered a market in equilibrium. The incredibly hot demand has been underreported and most buyer have to learn the hard way before getting realistic, writing offers below the asking price and losing out on a property or two. Another reality of the current marketplace is the number of hoops lenders will put you through in funding a loan. Buyers will not only put together the initial loan package; more often than not, the lender is going to request additional paperwork during the pending sale process. As of May 1st, the government imposed an additional hurdle which will change the appraisal process. This new process has a very high potential in delaying the close of a pending sale. It is my humble opinion that these additional hurdles are necessary, but should be postponed until the market has healed. It is easy for politicians to make headlines and change the way lending and appraising is processed in the midst of a downturn, but the real fixes need to come when the market is moving on all cylinders. | | | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | |   |   | | | | | | | |